Eminent Domain Vote Sparks Outrage Over Christ Episcopal Church
On April 30, 2025, the Toms River Township Council voted 4-3 to introduce an ordinance that would allow the town to seize Christ Episcopal Church’s 11-acre property at 415 Washington Street through eminent domain. The decision has ignited a firestorm of controversy, with many residents viewing it as a retaliatory move by Mayor Dan Rodrick against the church’s plan to establish a 17-bed homeless shelter. The community’s outrage is palpable, and the timing of this vote raises serious questions about the mayor’s motives.
The ordinance, which passed its first reading with support from Council President Justin Lamb, Vice President Craig Coleman, and council members Lynn O’Toole and William Byrne, aims to transform the church property into a recreational area with a playground, pickleball courts, a skate park, and a soccer field. Rodrick has argued that this would serve the 20,000 residents south of Route 37, claiming there are no adequate public parks in the downtown area. While the idea of new recreational space sounds appealing, many in Toms River see this as a thinly veiled attempt to block the church’s shelter proposal, which has faced fierce opposition from Rodrick and some local residents.
The sentiment in Toms River is one of betrayal and anger. Christ Episcopal Church, a 160-year-old congregation, is a community cornerstone, hosting over 20 support groups, a food pantry, and clothing distribution programs. The proposed shelter, in partnership with the Affordable Housing Alliance, would provide overnight accommodations, meals, and counseling for the unhoused—a critical need given Ocean County’s 28% increase in homelessness in 2024, with 556 people counted as unhoused. Residents are particularly incensed because the church property includes a memorial garden with the ashes of 300 parishioners, sacred ground that would be desecrated by the seizure. A Change.org petition started by the Rev. Lisa A. Hoffman has garnered nearly 2,900 signatures as of May 15, and a GoFundMe for legal fees raised over $2,900 in just 18 hours.
The timing of the ordinance adds fuel to the fire. The church has been seeking zoning approval for the shelter for months, a process that Rodrick has publicly opposed, alongside other homeless services like JBJ Soul Kitchen. The sudden introduction of the eminent domain ordinance, without formal notification to the church until a day prior, feels like a direct retaliation for the shelter plan. Rodrick insists the recreational project has been in development for over a year, but the lack of transparency and the rushed vote—coming just before the June 3 primary election—suggest political motives. Many believe Rodrick is using eminent domain to appease constituents opposed to the shelter, while avoiding a broader debate on homelessness solutions.
The church, backed by the Episcopal Diocese of New Jersey, is gearing up for a legal fight, with attorney Michael York calling the move “blatantly illegal” and a potential violation of the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act (RLUIPA). A final public hearing on the ordinance is set for May 28 at 4 p.m. at Toms River Town Hall, and the community is rallying to protect the church’s mission. Tomorrow, May 17, Republicans for Toms River will host a Meet & Greet from 4 p.m. to 6 p.m. at Garden State Distillery, featuring candidates Robert Bianchini, Clinton Bradley, Jim Quinlisk, and David Ciccozzi, who are running to restore integrity to the council. Afterward, head to the “Voices for the Voiceless” rally at 6:30 p.m. at the Toms River Library on Washington Street, where residents will continue to demand justice for the church and its vital outreach programs.